The
following piece is a response from Dr. Reinhold Schlieper to his students when
he was asked, “How do I get an “A” in your class”? Reading his message should
provide teachers, students, and parents with a better understanding of just
what an “A” student might look like.
One of my former students
raised a fascinating issue, he or she wrote on an evaluation: I never feel I
had a grasp on what I needed to do for a good grade. I feel I learned great
things that will help me in the future. One thing I would change in this class
is to give the student a better understanding of what to do for an A. Well, I
should try to spell out what to do for an 'A.' First, every student should
realize that an 'A' is not the result of the fulfillment of an contractual
agreement. Instead, the bare-bones fulfillment of the contractual agreement
usually certifies that a student has completed requirements satisfactorily. In
the short form, this is the grade 'C.' So, 'A' and 'B' students somehow manage
to deliver more than merely what they've contracted to do. They tend to surprise
me with demonstrating that they've understood the assignment and have gone
beyond its specific terms. No students should ever believe that an 'A' is
achievable by the teacher's giving a precise blueprint of what to do and by the
student's engaging in mindlessly following orders.
But in a more upbeat
manner, let me tell you what I have observed about students who typically get
an 'A' in one of my classes:
- 'A' students always attend class and come to class on
time; even if they have a class halfway across campus, they manage not to
be late.
- 'A' students never leave a workshop meeting early; they
generally find something to polish or to improve or to refine.
- 'A' students never ask me what I want from an assignment;
they're too busy visualizing what they could do with an assignment.
- 'A' students never haggle over grades; they try to look
for and to understand criticism constructively. That is, they want to
learn from what I point out to them.
- 'A' students are original and creative. Again, they
don't look to me for setting requirements; they look within themselves for
how they can go beyond requirements.
- 'A' students are meticulous. They do not proofread just
once; they proofread many times.
- 'A' students come to my office to discuss papers or
assignments that they are unsure of. Generally, I have a feeling that I'm
working WITH them, not that I'm on trial for unfair grading, when they
show up at my office.
- 'A' students cooperate with their team; they do not
spend time cutting each other down.
I suppose what I want to
say here is that being an 'A' student is an attitude, a mind set, a character
bend, or a morality or work ethic; it is not a bargain stance. "If I did
that, you must do that," is not a proper dialog mode for determining the
'A' student. I do hope that future students will read this comment; perhaps
that will help them immensely in setting their own standards. (Schlieper 1998).
Teachers
and parents may wish to share these thoughts with their students and/or
children.
If
you are a student and have just read Dr. Schlieper’s thoughts, it is time to
become an “A” student.
Reference:
Dr. Reinhold Schlieper
Department of Humanities
Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University
May 5, 1998